When it comes to funding workforce development, fund the connective tissue, not only the program. Intermediaries can hold the longer, harder, more relational work that strengthens the relationships that make workforce systems function.
A neighbourhood can get an influx of investments without creating meaningful work opportunities for the people who live there. It’s a central tension in workforce development right now. Across Toronto, new transit lines, mall redevelopments, and waves of construction are transforming communities.
But growth does not always equal local jobs.
Nowhere is that tension more visible than in Jane and Finch, a multicultural neighbourhood in the northwest of Toronto. More than 51,000 residents call it home, representing more than 120 nationalities and 100 languages, as one of Toronto’s youngest and most diverse communities. It’s an area with deep community infrastructure, a strong grassroots ecosystem, extraordinary resident leadership, and a workforce eager for good jobs, sitting inside an increasingly unaffordable city. Investment is pouring into Jane-Finch, too: for example, the $3.7-billion Finch West Light Rail Transit is now operational, and new transit, redevelopment, and real estate investment are reshaping the corridor around Finch Avenue West and Jane Street.
Left on its own, growth can just as easily pass through a neighbourhood as take root in it. The people who have called Jane-Finch home for generations are not looking for another top-down, one-size-fits-all approach for employment programming, which focuses more on job placements than it does on building real, sustainable careers. They’re looking for the growth happening around them to actually include them – in the hiring, the contracts, and the decisions.
The difference is not simply delivering programs to get people into jobs, in a particular neighbourhood; it is changing what we prioritize and how we work. Too often, we start with a standard employment program and ask how many people it can place in jobs. A “place-based approach” starts somewhere different: with the place itself. What jobs and investment are coming? Why is local talent not being hired? What barriers are residents facing? What do employers need? And how can local organizations, employers, and government work together to connect residents to those opportunities?
That is the case for place-based workforce development: an approach that designs employment solutions around the specific needs, assets, and people of a community, anchored by trusted local intermediaries – who connect job-seekers, employers, and government and are supported over time to build the relationships and pathways needed for real, lasting change. It is a case we need to make with more urgency this year than in the past. Workforce Funder Collaborative’s ask to fellow funders who are funding workforce development is simple: don’t just fund more employment programs. Fund the infrastructure, the intermediaries, the data, the shared tables that connect residents to the jobs, contracts, and decisions already arriving in their neighbourhood.
Why now
Labour markets are absorbing shock after shock, including trade disruption and the growing impact of artificial intelligence on hiring and jobs. Canada is not immune. Tariffs and trade uncertainty helped push national unemployment to a nine-year high of 7.9% in December 2025, while the economy shed roughly 112,000 jobs in the first four months of 2026. In Toronto, unemployment reached almost 8.9% in fall 2025.
These pressures will not affect everyone equally. They are likely to hit hardest in communities where residents already face barriers to work and have fewer connections to employers, training, transit, and job-search networks. That is where place-based workforce development can help. While global forces may shape where jobs are created or lost, the ability to access those jobs is deeply local.
That is the promise of place-based workforce development: designing employment solutions around the unique strengths and challenges of a community, its people, employers, institutions, transit, networks, and barriers. Rather than applying generic programs, it builds on local knowledge, trust, and accountability to create pathways to work that are more responsive and more durable.
To be clear, this work does not replace national/provincial policies or sector strategies. We need those to set direction, drive investment, and respond to broad economic shifts. Instead, what place-based workforce development can do is translate those broader strategies into opportunities that people can actually access where they live, connecting policy to the realities of local employers, neighbourhoods, and job-seekers.
What ‘place-based’ actually requires: an anchor
A recent workforce exchange, hosted by Toronto’s Workforce Funder Collaborative, brought together a group of workforce funders to explore a practical question: what does place-based workforce development actually look like?
Two examples helped bring the concept to life.
The Inclusive Local Economic Opportunity (ILEO) initiative, led by United Way Greater Toronto, focuses on five neighbourhoods, including Scarborough’s Greater Golden Mile – an area experiencing significant transformation through major transit investments and billions of dollars in planned redevelopment, including approximately $1.5 billion for the Golden Mile Shopping Centre redevelopment. Its central question is simple: how can economic growth benefit the residents who already call this community home?
ILEO brings together residents, community organizations, employers, developers, and governments to ensure that new investment translates into local jobs, training, procurement opportunities, and business growth. It also creates opportunities for community ownership: through the Centre for Inclusive Economic Opportunity (CIEO), the community holds a majority stake in Aecon–Golden Mile, a construction company designed to hire locally and reinvest profits in the community. Through the initiative, $20 million in financial return to community has been generated so far.
“The question wasn’t whether investment was coming to the Golden Mile,” says Tasleem Thawar, director of strategic initiatives at United Way Greater Toronto. “It was who would benefit when it arrived. New buildings and transit don’t automatically mean better jobs or more opportunities for the people already living there. Through ILEO, residents, businesses, community organizations, and governments work together so local people can get good jobs, grow businesses, and have a say in how their neighbourhood changes.”
The question wasn’t whether investment was coming . . . It was who would benefit when it arrived.
Tasleem Thawar, United Way Greater Toronto
On Fogo Island in Newfoundland and Labrador, social enterprise Shorefast offers a different but complementary model. Rooted in asset-based community development, Shorefast begins with what the community already has – its people, culture, skills, and natural assets – and builds economic opportunities around those strengths. Through initiatives such as the concept of “economic nutrition” – a pricing framework that shows where your money goes and who benefits from it – Shorefast tracks how value circulates locally, focusing not only on job creation, but on whether economic activity strengthens the broader community through local wages, suppliers, and reinvestment.
“At Shorefast, our approach to workforce development starts from the belief that businesses do the most for place-based economies when they put local first across every line of the budget,” says Tasha Freidus, a fellow at Shorefast. “Hiring locally is one part of a larger strategy that treats procurement as an opportunity to invest in the community.”
These approaches are different, but the lesson is similar: place-based work needs an anchor – a trusted intermediary that can hold relationships over time, connect community assets to economic opportunity, and make sure local voices have a role in shaping what happens next.
ILEO and Shorefast are also both intermediaries, acting as long-term connectors between communities, employers, and government. They’re present for long enough that a project can lead to real, lasting change; for example, by working with employers to create local hiring or procurement commitments, then staying involved to make sure those commitments lead to results. This role is often the missing infrastructure in workforce strategies.
We see the same principle in our own grantmaking in Jane-Finch. The Jane/Finch Centre has been rooted in the community for close to five decades, with a resident-led board and a long-standing role as a United Way anchor agency. It has built the kind of durable, cross-sector trust that place-based work depends on – coordinating with the city on neighbourhood planning, developing relationships with employers, and providing employment supports.
Through a grant from the Workforce Funder Collaborative, the centre is using that trust to build the connective infrastructure of a local labour market ecosystem, rather than simply delivering another stand-alone employment program. This includes deepening relationships with employers who can recruit and hire from the neighbourhood, strengthening pathways for job-seekers, and coordinating with other community organizations so residents are not navigating disconnected employment systems. The centre has been working for a number of years with employer-facing partners such as the Toronto Transit Commission and York University to build more consistent hiring pipelines through the Black Creek Fair Economies Project, building on local advocacy and efforts to secure community benefits and increase local hiring as the neighbourhood changes.
“An effective workforce strategy is based on relationships and trust,” says Michelle Dagnino, executive director of the Jane/Finch Centre. “We know our residents, we understand the barriers they are navigating, and we can bring employers and community partners to the same table. That is what allows us to move from individual job placements to longer-term pathways.”
An effective workforce strategy is based on relationships and trust.
Michelle Dagnino, Jane/Finch Centre
This is the work an intermediary can do that a program alone cannot: hold the whole picture – residents, employers, community organizations, and government – and stay with the work long enough to turn individual opportunities into lasting local change. It is difficult to capture in a one-year grant report, but without this connective infrastructure, training programs and employment services can remain disconnected from the larger economic forces shaping a neighbourhood.
The strongest place-based models therefore do not ask only how many people were hired. They ask who helped shape the opportunities, who benefits from economic growth, and what community assets remain after the investment is made. The question for funders is not just how many people got hired, but who holds power, who benefits from the economic value being created, and what remains in the community once the ribbon-cutting is over.
“The measure of success shouldn’t simply be how much investment comes into a neighbourhood,” Dagnino says. “It should be how much opportunity stays: in the form of good jobs, stronger local businesses, new skills, and greater economic security for the people who already call that community home.”
We do not need to invent a new vision
Toronto’s workforce development sector is busy. Every week brings another panel, report, pilot, or new initiative designed to strengthen pathways to employment. That energy is valuable, but effective place-based workforce development does not require us to sketch another vision for a neighbourhood. It’s tempting for funders to want their own framework, their own theory of change, their own logo on the road map. The better instinct is to ask what plan the community has already built, with residents at the table, and to align investment behind it.
The workforce dollars go further when they reinforce a shared direction the neighbourhood has already set, rather than adding one more disconnected initiative to the list – and in many communities, the vision already exists.
Jane-Finch is one example. The Jane-Finch Community Development Plan, shaped through extensive community engagement, already sets out a clear road map for creating inclusive economic opportunity, confronting anti-Black racism, and addressing the risks of gentrification and displacement. It recognizes a fundamental tension: investment and growth can either create new opportunities for existing residents or accelerate the forces that push them out.
A powerful takeaway from the workforce exchange was this: our usual measures don’t capture any of this. We’re good at counting participants and placements. We’re much worse at tracking what actually stays in a community. Both ILEO and Shorefast make an effort to show, in hard numbers, how much of the economic activity that a neighbourhood generates actually stays there, in wages, local hiring, procurement spend, retained profits, and community assets built over time.
If we want funders to take ownership and governance seriously, we need to start measuring for local economic outcomes, not just measuring program outputs.
The infrastructure we actually need
Toronto doesn’t need another stand-alone training program in Jane-Finch, or anywhere else facing similar pressures of transit expansion, redevelopment, or other large-scale investments. It needs more of what the Jane/Finch Centre, ILEO, and Shorefast all represent: an anchor organization trusted enough to hold employers, job seekers, and community priorities together over time, rooted in a vision the community itself defined.
“What has often been missing in workforce development strategies is a clear connection between the opportunities being created around them and the people who already live here,” Dagnino says. “Our role is to help build those connections with employers, community organizations, and residents, and make sure they last.”
As economic disruption accelerates, from AI to trade shocks, local infrastructure isn’t a nice-to-have. It’s the difference between a neighbourhood that absorbs change on someone else’s terms and one that shapes what change looks like for itself.
If funders want to make a real dent in this, the ask is straightforward: fund the connective tissue, not only the program. Support the intermediaries who can hold that longer, harder, more relational work, because that is the infrastructure that durable employment outcomes are actually built on. When funders invest in these organizations, they strengthen the relationships that make workforce systems function: deeper partnerships with local employers, stronger coordination among service providers, better understanding of community needs, and clearer pathways connecting residents to opportunity. The result is not just more programs delivered, but a stronger ecosystem capable of creating and sustaining employment pathways over time – ultimately leading to healthier, happier, and more resilient communities.